The Seasoned Wrench

The 5 Best Tires for Harley Softail: Performance and Durability Reviewed

Chase Manhattan Avatar

Last Updated:

Note: My posts may contain affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely believe in. Thanks for supporting The Seasoned Wrench!

Read my full affiliate disclaimer >>

When it comes to choosing the right tires for your Harley Softail, you know that performance and durability are key. You'll find that certain models stand out, like the Dunlop D404 and K591, which offer impressive grip in various conditions. But what about the best options for touring or everyday rides? Each tire has its unique strengths that can greatly influence your riding experience. You've got to take into account factors beyond just brand names or looks—so which tires truly deliver both performance and longevity? Let's explore the top contenders.

Quick Takeaways

  • Dunlop D404 offers enhanced wet grip and a load rating of 71, making it suitable for various riding conditions on Softail models.
  • Dunlop K591 features a directional tread pattern for superior grip, with a high load capacity of 805 lbs, ideal for sport and touring.
  • Dunlop D402 is the only tire approved by Harley for touring bikes, ensuring compatibility and stability with a three-ply construction.
  • Tread design significantly impacts performance; optimized designs enhance water evacuation and grip, crucial for safety in different weather conditions.
  • Matching front and rear tires is essential for optimal handling and stability, influencing overall bike performance and rider safety.

Dunlop D404 Rear Motorcycle Tire for Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic

dunlop d404 motorcycle tire

The Dunlop D404 Rear Motorcycle Tire is an excellent choice for Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic owners, particularly those with models from 2004 to 2006. This tire, sized at 150/80B-16, features a bias-belted construction that balances mileage and grip effectively. Designed with water evacuation in mind, its tread pattern enhances wet grip, ensuring safety during adverse conditions. With a load rating of 71, it can support up to 761 lbs, while the speed rating of H allows for speeds up to 130 mph. Regular tire maintenance, such as pressure checks and ensuring matching tires, is essential for ideal handling. Overall, the D404's robust design and positive customer feedback make it a reliable option for riders seeking performance and durability.

Best For: Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic owners looking for a durable and reliable rear tire that performs well in various conditions.

Pros:

  • Good mileage and grip: The tread compound offers a balanced performance for long-lasting use.
  • Designed for wet conditions: The tread pattern effectively manages water evacuation, enhancing safety.
  • Strong customer ratings: Positive feedback highlights durability and performance, with an overall rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars.

Cons:

  • Potential handling issues: Some users reported experiencing "death wobble" after installation.
  • Requires matching tires: It's crucial to use matching front and rear tires for optimal handling and stability.
  • Run-in period needed: New tires require a gentle break-in period of 100 miles before achieving full performance.

Dunlop Harley-Davidson K591 Rear Motorcycle Tire 160/70B-17

dunlop k591 motorcycle tire

Designed specifically for Harley-Davidson sport models, the Dunlop Harley-Davidson K591 Rear Motorcycle Tire 160/70B-17 stands out due to its directional tread pattern that guarantees superior grip in both wet and dry conditions. With a load capacity of 805 pounds, this tire provides a reliable performance for various Softail and Dyna models. Weighing in at 17.2 pounds and measuring 25.1 inches in diameter, it's built for year-round use and holds a speed rating of V. Originally designed for racing, the K591 has been refined for sport and sport-touring motorcycles, making it the only tire approved for Harley-Davidson sport models. Customer ratings average an impressive 4.9 out of 5, underscoring its performance and smooth ride.

Best For: Motorcycle enthusiasts looking for a high-performance rear tire specifically designed for Harley-Davidson sport models.

Pros:

  • Directional tread pattern enhances grip in both wet and dry conditions.
  • High load capacity of 805 pounds ensures reliability for various riding styles.
  • Outstanding customer ratings (4.9 out of 5) reflect positive feedback on performance and comfort.

Cons:

  • Limited compatibility as it is specifically designed for Harley-Davidson models.
  • Weight of 17.2 pounds may be heavier compared to some other motorcycle tires.
  • Price may be higher than generic motorcycle tires, potentially limiting budget-friendly options.

Dunlop D402 Rear Motorcycle Tire MT90B-16 (Wide White Wall)

dunlop d402 motorcycle tire

For Harley-Davidson Softail riders seeking a reliable and stylish tire, the Dunlop D402 Rear Motorcycle Tire MT90B-16 (Wide White Wall) stands out as the top choice. This tire is the only one approved by Harley-Davidson for touring bikes, ensuring compatibility with models like the Heritage Springer FLSTS from 1997 to 2002. Its three-ply polyester casing and dual fiberglass belts enhance load-carrying capacity and stability. The computer-optimized tread profile, featuring an offset center groove, boosts rider confidence on rain grooves and steel-grated surfaces while reducing cupping for even wear. With fast delivery and pricing that's cheaper than the Harley website, the Dunlop D402 combines performance and affordability, making it a smart pick for Softail enthusiasts.

Best For: Harley-Davidson Softail riders seeking a reliable and stylish tire for touring.

Pros:

  • Only tire approved by Harley-Davidson for touring bikes, ensuring optimal compatibility.
  • Enhanced stability and load-carrying capacity due to three-ply polyester casing and dual fiberglass belts.
  • Computer-optimized tread profile improves performance on various road conditions, reducing cupping for even wear.

Cons:

  • Limited compatibility primarily with specific Harley-Davidson models (1997-2002 Heritage Springer FLSTS).
  • May not be suitable for riders looking for a more aggressive off-road tire.
  • Availability may vary depending on location and demand.

Dunlop D402 Front Motorcycle Tire MH90-21 for Harley-Davidson Softail Custom FXSTC

dunlop d402 tire for harley

Crafted specifically for the Harley-Davidson Softail Custom FXSTC models from 1996 to 2007, the Dunlop D402 Front Motorcycle Tire MH90-21 stands out with its three-ply polyester casing and dual fiberglass belts. This construction provides greater load-carrying capacity and enhanced stability, making it an excellent choice for touring. The tire features a computer-optimized tread profile with an offset center groove, which helps reduce cupping and guarantees even wear. Riders appreciate its performance in various conditions, with a high speed rating of up to 130 MPH. Weighing 9.48 pounds and boasting a 4.2-star customer rating, the D402 offers year-round use and reliability. It's officially approved by Harley-Davidson, adding to its appeal for dedicated Softail enthusiasts.

Best For: riders of Harley-Davidson Softail Custom FXSTC models from 1996 to 2007 seeking a reliable and high-performance front tire for touring.

Pros:

  • Officially approved by Harley-Davidson for enhanced compatibility and performance.
  • Computer-optimized tread design reduces cupping and ensures even wear.
  • High speed rating of up to 130 MPH, suitable for various riding conditions.

Cons:

  • Limited size availability, specifically designed for certain Harley-Davidson models.
  • Weighs 9.48 pounds, which may be heavier compared to some other options.
  • Customer rating of 4.2 stars suggests mixed feedback from some users.

Dunlop D404 Rear Motorcycle Tire for Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic

dunlop d404 tire harley davidson

The Dunlop D404 Rear Motorcycle Tire stands out as an excellent choice for riders of the Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic FLST/C/I 2017, thanks to its bias-ply construction that enhances load capacity and comfort. This tire features a tread design that optimizes water evacuation, ensuring superior grip in wet conditions. The offset center groove contributes to improved straight-line stability, making it a reliable option for cruising. With a tread compound that balances durability and traction, riders can expect both mileage and performance. Garnering an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars from customer reviews, the D404 reinforces its reputation as a top-tier tire in the street motorcycle cruiser category, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable ride.

Best For: Riders of the Harley-Davidson Softail Heritage Classic FLST/C/I 2017 seeking a reliable and comfortable tire for cruising.

Pros:

  • Durable tread compound balances longevity and traction for various riding conditions.
  • Bias-ply construction provides enhanced load-carrying capacity and ride comfort.
  • High customer satisfaction with a rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars supports its reputation.

Cons:

  • Not recommended for use on Harley-Davidson motorcycles outside the specified model.
  • Limited size range may not suit all motorcycle brands or models.
  • Potential availability issues as indicated by its low best sellers rank.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Tires for Harley Softail

When you're choosing tires for your Harley Softail, it's essential to take into account several factors to guarantee the best fit and performance. You'll want to check tire size compatibility, load capacity requirements, and tread design features that suit your riding style. Additionally, reflect on seasonal performance and construction quality to get the most out of your investment.

Tire Size Compatibility

Choosing the right tire size for your Harley Softail is essential for guaranteeing ideal performance and safety on the road. Always refer to the manufacturer's specifications for your specific model. You might find that sizes like 150/80B-16 or 160/70B-17 are preferable for various Softail models.

Next, check the rim size, as many Softail Heritage models use a 16-inch rim, while others may require a 17-inch rim. It's also important to verify the tire's load rating, confirming it matches or exceeds your motorcycle's requirements. Common ratings for Softail tires include 71 (761 lbs) and 73 (805 lbs).

Don't overlook the tire's speed rating, which indicates the maximum speed the tire can safely handle. For Softail tires, you'll often see ratings like H (130 mph) and V. Finally, consider the type of tire construction, as many Softail tires feature bias-belted designs that enhance stability and comfort while riding. By paying attention to these compatibility factors, you can guarantee a smoother, safer ride on your Harley Softail.

Load Capacity Requirements

Tire load capacity plays a significant role in the overall performance and safety of your Harley Softail. When choosing tires, it's essential to confirm that the tire's load capacity meets or exceeds your motorcycle's weight, as indicated by the tire's load rating. For instance, tires like the Dunlop D404 have a load rating of 71, supporting up to 761 lbs.

Exceeding the maximum load can lead to tire failure or decreased handling stability, which could compromise your safety on the road. Each tire's load range, such as the Dunlop D402 with a load range of B, indicates its ability to carry weight, so match it appropriately to your motorcycle's specifications.

Consider the cumulative weight of you, any passengers, and cargo when evaluating the required load capacity for your tires. Regularly checking tire pressure and confirming it aligns with the manufacturer's recommendations helps maintain the tire's load-carrying capacity. This not only optimizes performance but also extends the lifespan of your tires, guaranteeing you get the most out of your Harley Softail riding experience. Prioritize load capacity; your ride depends on it.

Tread Design Features

While selecting the right tires for your Harley Softail, understanding tread design features is vital for maximizing your riding experience. The tread design greatly influences water evacuation and wet grip, enhancing your safety during rainy rides. Look for directional tread patterns, as they're specifically engineered to provide optimum grip in both wet and dry conditions, improving your overall handling and control.

An offset center groove in the tread profile can also enhance straight-line stability, contributing to a smoother ride. It's important to choose a tire with a well-optimized tread design to reduce cupping, ensuring even wear and prolonging the lifespan of your tire. This not only leads to cost savings but also enhances your riding confidence.

Additionally, pay attention to the balance of mileage and grip offered by the tread compound. A tire that maintains performance over extended use while still providing adequate traction is vital for a fulfilling riding experience. By considering these tread design features, you'll be better equipped to choose tires that meet your performance and safety needs for your Harley Softail.

Seasonal Performance Considerations

Selecting the right tires for your Harley Softail involves more than just picking a brand; seasonal performance considerations play a significant role in your overall riding experience. First, examine the tire's tread pattern. Directional designs enhance grip in both wet and dry conditions, critical for safety. As temperatures fluctuate with the seasons, remember that tire pressure can change too. Regular inspections and adjustments will help maintain ideal performance and handling throughout the year.

Next, focus on the tread compound. A balanced tread will provide both mileage and grip, allowing your tires to withstand varying road conditions and rider demands. Don't overlook the load capacity; selecting tires with the appropriate load rating is essential, especially if you're carrying extra weight or riding two-up.

Construction Quality Standards

When it comes to choosing tires for your Harley Softail, construction quality standards are essential for guaranteeing a safe and enjoyable ride. First, consider the bias-ply construction commonly found in tires designed for Harley models. This design enhances load-carrying capacity and ride comfort due to its flexible sidewalls, making it ideal for long-distance touring and cruising.

Next, look for tires that incorporate multiple plies, such as nylon or polyester. These materials improve stability and durability, significant for maintaining performance under various riding conditions. The tread design also plays an important role; directional patterns optimize grip while effectively evacuating water, enhancing safety during wet rides.

Additionally, high-quality motorcycle tires often utilize advanced tread compounds that strike a balance between mileage and grip. This guarantees your tires last longer without compromising on traction. Finally, always choose tires that are officially approved by manufacturers for your specific Harley model. This approval ensures compliance with the safety and performance standards that your motorcycle demands. By focusing on these construction quality standards, you'll make an informed choice that elevates your riding experience.

Handling and Stability

For ideal handling and stability on your Harley Softail, it's important to take into account several key factors when choosing tires. First, always match your front and rear tires; mixing tire types can seriously compromise your bike's performance. The tire's construction is another significant aspect—bias-belted tires provide a softer ride and improved comfort, while radial tires offer better handling dynamics.

Tread patterns also play an important role. They influence water evacuation and wet grip, which is necessary for maintaining stability during adverse weather conditions. You want tires that can handle rain efficiently to keep you safe on the road.

Don't forget about tire pressure maintenance. Under-inflated tires can lead to poor handling and increased wear, while over-inflation reduces your contact with the road, making your ride less stable.

Lastly, consider the load rating of the tires. Each tire's design and materials affect how well it handles varying weight conditions. Ensuring you choose tires with an adequate load capacity is crucial for safe operation and maximum performance. Prioritize these factors, and you'll enjoy a smoother, more stable ride on your Harley Softail.

Price and Value

Finding the right tires for your Harley Softail involves more than just picking a brand; it's about balancing price and value. Start by comparing prices across different retailers. You might find better deals than what's offered directly on brand websites, which can save you money.

Next, consider the tire's performance features relative to its price. Higher-priced options often come with advanced tread designs and enhanced durability, potentially reducing your long-term replacement costs. Don't forget to check customer feedback and ratings. Tires with higher ratings usually indicate better reliability and performance for the price you pay.

Warranty and return policies also play an important role. Tires backed by robust guarantees can provide greater value by minimizing future costs associated with replacements. Additionally, verify the tire's load capacity and specifications match your bike's requirements. Choosing the right tire helps prevent costly issues related to handling and safety, keeping you on the road longer without worries.

Ultimately, take the time to evaluate all these factors to make an informed decision that balances price with the value you'll gain from your tires.

Common Questions

How Often Should I Replace My Harley Softail Tires?

You should replace your Harley Softail tires every 5,000 to 10,000 miles, depending on your riding style and conditions. Regularly check for tread wear, cracks, or punctures, and don't ignore vibrations or handling issues—these can signal it's time for a change. If you ride in varied conditions, you might want to inspect them more frequently. Keeping an eye on your tires guarantees a safer and smoother ride every time you hit the road.

Can I Mix Different Tire Brands on My Softail?

You can mix different tire brands on your Softail, but it's not the best idea. Different brands may have varying tread patterns, rubber compounds, and handling characteristics, which can affect stability and performance. If you choose to do so, make certain the tire design is compatible and that both tires are suitable for your riding style. Always prioritize safety by checking the load ratings and maintaining proper air pressure for peak performance.

What Tire Pressure Is Recommended for Harley Softail Tires?

When it comes to tire pressure for your Harley Softail, think of it as the heartbeat of your ride. You'll want to keep it between 36 to 40 psi for the front tire and 40 to 42 psi for the rear tire. This sweet spot guarantees peak performance and safety. Always check your tire pressure regularly, especially before long rides, to keep your bike handling like a dream on the open road.

Do Tire Warranties Cover Road Hazard Damage?

When it comes to tire warranties, they often vary by manufacturer. Generally, standard warranties don't cover road hazard damage like punctures or sidewall damage caused by debris. However, some brands offer specific road hazard protection plans that you can purchase separately. It's important to read the terms carefully, so you know what's covered. Make sure to check with your tire dealer for the best options available for your specific needs.

How Can I Tell if My Tires Are Worn Out?

You might think your tires are invincible, but they're not! To tell if they're worn out, check for tread depth; if it's less than 2/32 inches, it's time for a change. Look for cracks, bulges, or uneven wear too. If you can see the wear indicators, those little bars between the tread, it's waving a white flag. Don't ignore these signs—your safety depends on those tires, so keep a close eye on them!

Wrapping Up

In the world of Harley Softail tires, finding the right fit is like discovering a hidden gem. The Dunlop options we've explored offer a blend of performance and durability, ensuring you ride with confidence on any road. Whether you're cruising through rain or basking in the sun, these tires will keep you grounded. So, gear up, hit the road, and let the adventure unfold—your Softail deserves the best, and with these tires, you're ready to roll!