The Seasoned Wrench

7 Best Batteries for Harley Davidson Softail Motorcycles – Power Up Your Ride

Chase Manhattan Avatar

Last Updated:

Note: My posts may contain affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely believe in. Thanks for supporting The Seasoned Wrench!

Read my full affiliate disclaimer >>

When it comes to enhancing the performance of your Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle, the choice of battery can make a significant difference. From the reliable NOCO Lithium NLP20 to the versatile PowerStar replacement, these top 7 batteries offer a range of features tailored to meet your riding needs. Whether you prioritize power output, longevity, or maintenance convenience, these batteries are designed to power up your ride efficiently. But, before you make your selection, there is one pivotal factor you wouldn’t want to overlook.

Things to Note

  • Choose AGM or lithium batteries for Softail models.
  • Consider power needs and maintenance requirements.
  • Ensure perfect fit and compatibility with your bike.
  • Check warranty lengths and brand reputation.
  • Balance price with quality and warranty for value.
high performance lightweight lithium battery

The NOCO Lithium NLP20 Motorcycle Battery is the best choice for Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle owners seeking unmatched starting power and long-lasting reliability. With 600A starting power, 7Ah capacity, and 89Wh energy, this 12V Lithium Powersports Battery outperforms lead-acid alternatives without necessitating maintenance or water.

Designed for 50,000 start cycles and 2,000 charge cycles, it guarantees durability. The built-in Battery Management System (BMS) enhances safety and provides active cell balancing. Compatible with various powersports brands, the NOCO NLP20 replaces multiple lead-acid battery models effortlessly.

Offering superfast charging, universal multi-terminal configuration, and accessories like battery terminals and mounting brackets, this lightweight and compact battery at 2.38 pounds and 7.83D x 7.64W x 8.15H inches is a reliable choice for enhancing motorcycle performance.

Best For: Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle owners seeking unmatched starting power and long-lasting reliability.

Pros:

  • 600A starting power and 7Ah capacity for excellent performance.
  • Long-lasting durability with 50,000 start cycles and 2,000 charge cycles.
  • Lightweight and compact design with superfast charging capabilities.

Cons:

  • Some users may find the initial cost higher compared to traditional lead-acid batteries.
  • Warranty claim process may require detailed information and proof of purchase.
  • Compatibility with certain powersports brands may vary, requiring additional research before purchase.
motorcycle battery for harley

Ideal for Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle owners seeking a reliable and maintenance-free battery replacement, the PowerStar YTX20HL-BS AGM battery offers a high recovery capability and a 3-year warranty.

This 12V 18AH 400CCA AGM sealed battery boasts dimensions of L= 6.94, W= 3.13, H= 6.00, ensuring a perfect fit for the FXST FLST Softail 1450CC 00-06 models. Its leak-free and sealed design prevents corrosion, making it a hassle-free option.

The PowerStar battery is a 100% compatible OEM replacement for various vehicles, including motorcycles, ATVs, and personal watercraft. With a set terminal and six cells, this medium-sized battery from BatteryJack, Inc. weighs 12 pounds and comes with a UPC of 843443185992.

Customers have rated it 3.9 out of 5 stars, with feedback highlighting its spill-proof nature and low self-discharge feature.

Best For: Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle owners looking for a reliable, maintenance-free battery replacement with high recovery capability and a 3-year warranty.

Pros:

  • Leak-free and sealed design prevents corrosion
  • Maintenance-free, no need to add acid
  • 100% compatible OEM replacement for various vehicles

Cons:

  • Mixed feedback from customers
  • Some reported issues with charging indicators
  • Suggestions for improvement and local purchase alternatives mentioned
high performance agm battery

Offering high performance and maintenance-free reliability, the Weize YTX20HL-BS Battery is a top choice for riders seeking a dependable power source for their Harley Davidson Softail Motorcycles.

With dimensions of 6.89′ x 3.43′ x 6.10′ and a weight of 12.76 Lbs, this 12V battery boasts a capacity of 18AH and a CCA of 300, ensuring a powerful start every time.

The sealed lead-acid absorbed glass mat (AGM) design eliminates the need for maintenance, making it a hassle-free option. While some users reported fitment issues and challenges with the terminal nut design during installation, many praised its ability to start the bike effectively.

Backed by a 30-day return policy and a 1-year warranty, the Weize YTX20HL-BS Battery provides peace of mind to riders relying on its performance.

Best For: Riders of Harley Davidson Softail Motorcycles seeking a powerful and reliable maintenance-free battery option.

Pros:

  • High performance with 12V voltage and 18AH capacity
  • Sealed AGM design eliminates maintenance needs
  • Pre-charged, fits various vehicle models, and comes with a 1-year warranty

Cons:

  • Reported fitment issues in some vehicles
  • Challenges with terminal nut design during installation
  • Mixed customer reviews on battery performance
high performance battery replacement

Catering to Harley-Davidson FXSTDI Softail Deuce owners, the Mighty Max Battery YTX20L-BS is a reliable choice for durable performance and efficient power supply. Weighing 14 pounds with dimensions of 6.88 x 3.42 x 6.1 inches, this battery is designed to fit the specific needs of the Softail Deuce model.

With an average rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars from 13 customer reviews, it’s evident that users appreciate its quality. The battery’s manufacturer, Mighty Max Battery, offers a voluntary 30-day return guarantee through Amazon.com, providing users with added peace of mind.

Customers have reported positive experiences with shipping and customer service, reinforcing the battery’s reputation for quality and reliability.

Best For: Harley-Davidson FXSTDI Softail Deuce owners seeking a reliable and efficient battery solution.

Pros:

  • Durable performance tailored for the specific needs of the Softail Deuce model.
  • Positive customer feedback on battery quality.
  • Voluntary 30-day return guarantee for added peace of mind.

Cons:

  • Average rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars may indicate room for improvement.
  • Limited warranty and support options compared to some competitors.
  • Higher weight compared to other batteries in the market.
high performance battery for harley

With its high discharge rate and wide operating temperatures, the Mighty Max Battery YTX20L-BS is an exceptional choice for riders seeking a durable and reliable power source for their Harley-Davidson FLSTN Softail Deluxe.

This 12V 18AH 270 CCA battery features dimensions of 6.88′ x 3.42′ x 6.10′ and a sealed lead acid (SLA) design that allows for mounting in any position. Known for its long service life and ability to recover from deep discharges, this battery is resistant to shocks and vibrations, ensuring long-lasting high performance.

Backed by a 30-day refund policy and a full 1-year warranty from Mighty Max Battery, riders can trust in the quality and support provided by this model.

Best For: Riders of Harley-Davidson FLSTN Softail Deluxe seeking a durable and reliable power source.

Pros:

  • High discharge rate and wide operating temperatures.
  • Long service life and deep discharge recovery.
  • Resistant to shocks and vibrations for long-lasting high performance.

Cons:

  • Limited 30-day refund policy.
  • Weighs 14 pounds, which may affect handling.
  • Warranty and support are provided by the manufacturer, which may involve shipping costs for returns.
harley davidson flstf battery replacement

Ideal for riders of Harley Davidson FLSTF Softail Fat Boy motorcycles between 1991 and 2014, the Mighty Max Battery YTX20L-BS offers a high discharge rate and long service life.

This 12V 18AH 270 CCA sealed lead acid battery is designed with dimensions of 6.88′ x 3.42′ x 6.10′, providing a perfect fit for the specified Harley-Davidson models.

Known for its wide operating temperatures and deep discharge recovery, the YTX20L-BS is rechargeable and mountable in any position, ensuring versatility and convenience. Additionally, its shock and vibration-resistant construction enhance durability during rides.

Backed by a 30-day refund policy and a 1-year warranty, this battery from Mighty Max Battery delivers reliable performance and peace of mind to riders of Harley-Davidson FLSTF Softail Fat Boy motorcycles.

Best For: Riders of Harley Davidson FLSTF Softail Fat Boy motorcycles between 1991 and 2014 seeking a high discharge rate and long service life in a sealed lead acid battery.

Pros:

  • High discharge rate and long service life
  • Versatile and convenient with mountable design in any position
  • Shock and vibration-resistant construction for enhanced durability

Cons:

  • Specific compatibility with limited Harley-Davidson models between 1991-2014
  • May be heavier compared to other battery options
  • Limited customer reviews available for reference
high performance harley battery

The YTX20HL-BS Rechargeable Power Sports Battery is a top choice for Harley Davidson Softail Motorcycle owners due to its reliable performance and low maintenance design. This AGM battery with Nut & Bolt terminal technology offers a spill-proof and low maintenance solution for various vehicles, including motorcycles, ATVs, and jet skis.

Fully charged upon delivery, it features patented sealed posts for extended life. With 6 cells, 18 Amps, and 216.00 Wattage, this Chrome Battery product from China is known for its rechargeable nature, mountable in any position, and Polarity: [- +].

While some users praise its performance and fit for Harley Davidson bikes, others have reported issues with initial charging and longevity, as well as some compatibility concerns.

Best For: Harley Davidson Softail Motorcycle owners looking for a reliable, low maintenance battery solution.

Pros:

  • Fully charged upon delivery for immediate use
  • Spill-proof and low maintenance AGM technology
  • Rechargeable and mountable in any position for convenience

Cons:

  • Some users experienced issues with initial charging and longevity
  • Mixed opinions on terminal design and value for the price
  • Compatibility concerns reported with certain vehicle models

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Battery for Harley Davidson Softail

When selecting a battery for your Harley Davidson Softail, you should consider the type of battery that best suits your needs, analyze the power requirements of your motorcycle, and guarantee that the battery fits and is compatible with your bike.

Evaluate the maintenance needs of the battery and compare warranties to make an informed decision on the best choice for your Softail.

Battery Type Considerations

Considerations for selecting a battery type for your Harley Davidson Softail include evaluating the advantages of AGM and lithium options based on your specific requirements and budget. AGM batteries are maintenance-free, spill-proof, and suitable for traditional Harley Davidson motorcycles, offering reliability and deep discharge recovery. They’re a solid choice for various Softail models.

On the other hand, lithium batteries provide lightweight construction, quick starting power, longer lifespan, and improved performance due to reduced weight compared to AGM batteries. Understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision tailored to your riding style, maintenance preferences, and financial constraints.

Whether you prioritize reliability and compatibility with AGM batteries or seek enhanced performance and longevity with lithium options, selecting the right battery type is essential for powering up your Harley Davidson Softail and optimizing your riding experience.

Power Requirements Analysis

To make sure your Harley Davidson Softail operates at its peak, analyze the power requirements when selecting a suitable battery. Start by considering the voltage, typically 12V for Softail models, and the capacity measured in ampere-hours.

It’s crucial to assess the battery’s dimensions to confirm it fits properly in the Softail’s battery compartment. Look for maintenance-free options like sealed lead-acid (SLA) or Absorbed Glass Mat (AGM) batteries for convenience.

Additionally, check the warranty and return policy to ensure peace of mind and support in case of any battery-related issues. By paying attention to these power requirements, you can choose a battery that not only fits your Harley Davidson Softail but also provides the necessary power for top performance.

Fitment and Compatibility

How important is it to ensure the battery you choose for your Harley Davidson Softail is specifically designed for seamless fitment and compatibility?

It’s essential to select a battery that’s tailored to fit your Softail model perfectly. Ensuring compatibility with your bike’s electrical system and power requirements is necessary to prevent any operational issues.

Opt for batteries that serve as direct OEM replacements to guarantee proper fitment and excellent performance. Additionally, consider the physical dimensions of the battery to make sure it securely fits within the designated compartment of your Softail.

Checking that the battery terminals align correctly with your bike’s wiring system is also crucial to avoid any connectivity problems. By prioritizing fitment and compatibility, you can enhance the efficiency and longevity of your Harley Davidson Softail’s battery, providing you with a reliable and seamless riding experience.

Maintenance Needs Evaluation

Evaluate the battery’s care requirements, focusing on factors such as charging needs and periodic upkeep tasks, to make an informed choice for your Harley Davidson Softail.

When selecting a battery for your Softail, consider if it demands regular care tasks like adding water or electrolyte. These tasks can affect convenience and upkeep costs.

Opting for maintenance-free alternatives such as sealed AGM batteries can eliminate the need for regular care, providing ease of use and convenience. Neglecting upkeep can lead to premature failure, impacting both the battery’s lifespan and performance.

To ensure trouble-free operation and peak performance for your Harley Davidson Softail, choose a battery with low care requirements.

Warranty Comparison Check

Consider the warranty lengths and coverage offered by various battery brands for Harley Davidson Softail models when selecting the ideal power source for your motorcycle.

Check if the warranty includes protection against defects, malfunctions, or premature failures. It’s vital to opt for warranties that outline a clear process for returns, replacements, or refunds in case of issues.

Evaluate the manufacturer’s reputation as it can indicate the reliability of the warranty provided. Additionally, look for any extra benefits or terms included in the warranty, such as complimentary replacements or extended coverage options.

A strong warranty can offer peace of mind and potentially save you money in the long run. Prioritize batteries that come with extensive warranties to guarantee that you’re covered in various situations that may arise during the lifespan of your Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle.

Brand Reputation Review

When selecting a battery for your Harley Davidson Softail, the brand’s reputation is an essential aspect to keep in mind for guaranteeing quality and reliability. Researching the brand’s history, customer reviews, and industry recognition can provide valuable insights into the battery’s performance. Established brands with a positive reputation are more likely to offer durable and high-quality batteries that meet the demands of your motorcycle.

Brands known for their innovation, technology, and exceptional customer service are often the preferred choices among Harley Davidson Softail owners. By choosing a brand with a track record of producing batteries that not only meet but exceed industry standards, you can be confident in selecting a trustworthy option for your bike.

Prioritizing brand reputation when making your battery selection can secure that you invest in a reliable power source that enhances your riding experience and provides long-lasting performance on the road.

Price and Value

Finding the right balance between price and quality is necessary when selecting a battery for your Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle. Battery options for Harley Davidson Softail models vary in price, ranging from budget-friendly choices to more premium selections.

When evaluating the value of a battery, consider factors such as features, performance, warranty, and longevity it offers. It’s vital to compare the cost-effectiveness of the battery by evaluating its price, durability, maintenance needs, and compatibility with your bike.

Look for batteries that strike a balance between affordability and quality to guarantee a worthwhile investment for your Harley Davidson Softail. Don’t forget to factor in any additional costs like installation fees or maintenance expenses when gauging the overall value of the battery.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Install the Battery Myself or Do I Need a Professional?

You can install the battery yourself as long as you follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. It’s a relatively straightforward process that doesn’t usually require professional help.

Just make sure to disconnect the old battery properly, install the new one correctly, and tighten all connections securely. Always remember to wear protective gear and consult your motorcycle’s manual for specific guidance on battery replacement.

How Long Is the Warranty on the Battery?

You can count on a solid warranty with these batteries. In fact, the warranty lasts for a generous five years.

So, if you encounter any issues during this time, you can rest assured knowing that you’re covered.

This warranty provides you with peace of mind and guarantees that you can enjoy your rides without worrying about battery troubles for a long time.

Will This Battery Fit All Softail Models?

Yes, this battery will fit all Softail models. It’s designed to be compatible with a range of Harley Davidson motorcycles, ensuring that it will work seamlessly with your specific Softail model.

You can count on this battery to deliver reliable power and performance for your ride, without any compatibility issues. Enjoy the peace of mind knowing that this battery is a perfect fit for your Harley Davidson Softail.

Are There Any Specific Maintenance Requirements for the Battery?

To maintain your battery running smoothly, make sure to:

  • Check the terminals for corrosion regularly and clean them if needed.
  • Confirm proper water levels if you have a flooded battery type.
  • Tighten any loose connections.
  • Store your motorcycle in a cool, dry place during long periods of inactivity to extend battery life.

Regular maintenance will help keep your battery in top condition for your rides.

Does the Battery Come Pre-Charged and Ready to Use?

Yes, the battery comes pre-charged and ready to use. It’s convenient because you can install it right away without having to wait for a charge.

This feature guarantees that you can power up your ride quickly and efficiently. Just make sure to follow the proper installation instructions to get your Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle ready to hit the road smoothly.

Conclusion

So, now that you know the 7 best batteries for your Harley Davidson Softail motorcycle, it’s time to power up your ride and hit the road with confidence.

Don’t let a dead battery slow you down – invest in a reliable and high-performance battery today.

And remember, with options ranging from lightweight lithium to maintenance-free AGM, there’s a battery choice for every rider’s needs.

Don’t wait – upgrade your Softail’s battery now and enjoy a hassle-free ride every time!